Does NSW need a Multicultural March right now?
UN's IPCC chief Rajendra Pachauri resigns

Hizb ut-Tahrir statement on the Australian Government's national security strategy

 

Screen Shot 2015-02-25 at 7.04.32 am

Abbott Government scapegoats Islam and Muslims for consequences of western state violence

  • Monday, 23 February 2015 14:25
 
Abbott Government scapegoats Islam and Muslims for consequences of western state violence
 

Prime Minister Tony Abbott delivered his much-awaited National Security Statement yesterday, 23 February 2015, in which he claimed that the “terrorist threat” is rising and flagged new security measures on citizenship, immigration and welfare. The overall lack of any new substance in the statement confirmed the view that this was little more than a cheap exercise in fear politics.

Hizb ut-Tahrir Australia emphasises the following in response to the content of the Statement:

1. The statement continues the disingenuous approach of western states of seeking to alter the victim-aggressor paradigm. The aggressors – powerful states whose violence is responsible for the blood of millions – are duplicitously painted as the victims. In truth, the wrong reactions of some to neo-colonial brutality does not change the fact that that brutality is the original aggression and the fundamental problem. Preventing the action would prevent the reaction. Continuing the aggression is a recipe for perpetuating the problem, which is all we’ve seen in the last 14 years of the ‘War on Terror’.

2. In claiming that no grievances or causes are behind the violence, it is the Abbott Government who excuses and justifies terrorism. It excuses and justifies the “primitive savagery” inflicted on entire populations in Iraq and Afghanistan by its allies. It excuses and justifies the systemic violence inflicted on entire peoples by the despotic regimes it supports such as the regimes in Egypt and Saudi Arabia.

3. The emphasis on revoking citizenship, restricting immigration and denying welfare is indeed “window dressing” playing to right-wing racist opinion on these subjects. Otherwise, it is rather plain that those intent on doing the wrong thing will not stop based on considerations of citizenship or welfare. Indeed, these measures continue to build on the now well-established two-tier legal system in this country: one set of laws for Muslims and another for everyone else.

4. Tony Abbott paints the Australian establishment as good-natured, tolerant, decent, and accepting. The children of Iraq killed first by heartless sanctions and then war would beg to differ. The children of asylum seekers drowned out at sea or incarcerated in prisons like criminals would beg to differ. The children of Gaza, killed playing on the beach or lying in hospital, would beg to differ. The children killed by US drones in Pakistan and Yemen would beg to differ. Who does Tony Abbott think he is fooling?

5. If the “terrorist threat” is rising at home and abroad, as claimed, the current “counter-terrorism” approach – more laws, more surveillance and more soft-power intrusion in the Muslim community - applied consistently for 14 years now, is surely a failed approach. The Prime Minister should admit this, instead of offering more of the same.

6. The Coalition Government, with sheepish support from Labour, is directly targeting Islam and Muslims under the pretext of fighting violence. It is notable that all the examples of prosecutions, incidents and groups used in the National Security Statement were of Muslims. No mention of the planned violent acts by non-Muslims like the Pullenvale case. No mention of “hate preachers” like the Australian Defence League. No mention of “extreme ideology” like that of various Zionist groups. No mention of “foreign fighters” who travel to train and fight with the IDF.

7. Hizb ut-Tahrir rejects the charge of preaching hate or spreading discord and division. It is those in the political establishment and media who constantly demonise Islam and Muslims and partake in a cheap politics of fear that spread discord and division. War creates hatred, not speaking against it. Blind support for an unjust and brutal invasions like “Israel” which has pushed three generations of a people into slums creates hatred, not speaking against this. Dictating and imposing religious beliefs create hatred, not speaking against this.

8. The promise of “stronger prohibitions of vilification” once again exposes the hypocrisy of liberal freedoms. When the Prophet (saw) is insulted and vilified, it is justified in the name of free speech. Yet when Muslims account unjust foreign and domestic policies, even without insults, they are threatened with vilification laws.

9. The call for Islam to be reformed and Muslim leaders to do more is a continuation of the heaping of collective blame for violence on Muslims. It is a slap in the face of those Muslims who have for years already been saying, “Islam means peace” and offering condemnations and apologies for western consumption. The Muslim community has commendably refused this. She must now adopt a principled stance of placing the focus where it should: on western state violence and excesses.

10. It is not Islam that needs reformation. Islam has a thousand year history of different peoples living peacefully together under the Caliphate, with prosperity and safety for all. In sharp contrast, liberal democracies cannot point to even one example in a 300-year history where minorities were not abused and/or scapegoated for the systemic failures of the state and society – precisely what is occurring in our present case. At its essence, what we are seeing is a slow but sure move in western states towards authoritarianism – poignantly symbolised by the Prime Minister’s choice of venue and introductory celebration of the AFP, ADF and ASIO – to preempt the inevitable and growing unrest caused by systemic failures. Fear of Muslims is just a convenient scapegoat.

Media Office
Hizb ut-Tahrir Australia
24 Feb 2015

 

The Hizb ut-Tahrir organisation published a similar statement on 19 February - that statement carried these signatures:

Signatories:

Organisations, Mosques and Community Initiatives

Ahlul Sunnah wal Jamah Association New South Wales

Ahlul Sunnah wal Jamah Association Victoria

Al Noor Islamic Association [Masijd Nur] [Sydney, NSW]

Australian Muslim Advocates for the Rights of All Humanity [Brisbane, Queensland]

Ansar Sisters [Youth Group]

Assalam Initiative [Indonesian community organisation]

Auburn Islamic Center / Arcade Mosque [Sydney, NSW]

Australian Islamic Mission – Punchbowl Mosque [Sydney, NSW]

Australian Muslim Faces Portal

Australian Muslim Voice

Azhar Mosque [Belmore, Sydney]

Baytal Hikmah Islamic Center [Melbourne, Victoria]

Cumberland University Muslim Students Association [CMS] [NSW]

DawahMatrix [Queensland]

Fajar Islam – Indonesian Community organisation [Sydney]

Federation of Australian Muslim Students and Youth (FAMSY) Queensland

Fitzroy Mosque [Melbourne, Victoria]

Forum on Australia’s Islamic Relations [FAIR]

Forum Pengajin Jum’at – Indonesian Community organisation [Sydney]

Global Islamic Youth Centre [GIYC] [Sydney, NSW]

Gold Coast Mosque [Queensland]

Hiraa Muslim Sisters of Canberra [Muslim Women’s Association]

Hizb ut-Tahrir Australia

Indonesian Islamic Association Inc. Sydney

Islam in Focus Australia [Queensland]

Islamic Awareness Forum of UNSW [IAFUNSW] [NSW]

Islamic Council of Western Australia

Islamic Information and Services Network of Australasia [IISNA] [Victoria]

Islamic Society of Belconnen [ISB] [Australian Capital Territory]

Islamic Society of Deakin University [Victoria]

Islamic Society of Gold Coast [Queensland]

Islamic Society of Victoria University [Victoria]

Islamicate [Educational institution]

IslaminAustralia.Com Web Portal

Keluarga Jawa Timur – East Java Community [Sydney]

La Trobe University Islamic Society [Victoria]

Macquarie University Muslim Students Association [MUMSA] [NSW]

Monash University Islamic Society [Victoria]

Muslim Debate Initiative Australia [MDI]

Muslims in Medicine [University of New South Wales] [NSW]

Muslim Legal Network Western Australia

Muslim Students Association of Victoria [peak body]

Muslim Women Welfare and Advocacy Association of Western Australia

Noble Park Mosque [Bosnian community] [Victoria]

Preston Mosque [Victoria]

Raudhatul ‘Ilmi – Indonesian community organisation [Sydney]

Regents Park Mosque [Sydney, NSW]

RMIT University Islamic Society [Victoria]

Salam Care [Muslim NGO]

Sefton Mosque [Sydney, NSW]

Shepparton Mosque [Melbourne, Victoria]

Sharjah Islamic Association [Queensland]

Sisters’ House Services Inc Qld [Queensland]

Slacks Creek Mosque [Queensland]

Somali Organisation for Development Aid [SODA]

Stories in the Park Initiative [Sydney]

Swinburne University Islamic Society [Victoria]

Sydney University Muslim Students Association [SUMSA] [NSW]

Taqwah Mosque, Canberra [Australian Capital Territory]

The Islam Project

University of Melbourne Islamic Society [Victoria]

University of Technology Sydney Muslim Students [UTSMS] [NSW]

University of Western Sydney Muslim Students Association [UWSMSA Bankstown] [NSW]

University of Western Sydney Muslim Students Association [UWSMSA Campbelltown] [NSW]

University of Western Sydney Muslim Students Association [UWSMSA Parramatta] [NSW]

Werribee Mosque [Melbourne, Victoria]

Western Australia Muslim Lawyers Association

Prominent personalities [Scholars, activists, commentators]

Aamer Rahman [Social Commentator and Comedian, Victoria]

Abdurrahman Crossingham J.P. [Community Activist, NSW]

Almir Colan – Australian Centre for Islamic Finance [AusCif]

Ataman Atlas [Barrister/Solicitor]

Baha Yehia [Community Activist, Victoria]

Dr Rateb Jneid [President, Islamic Council of Western Australia]

Dr. Tamer Kahil [Community Activist]

Dr. Daud AbdulFattah Batchelor [Co-founder of the Islamic College of Brisbane]

Hanan Dover [Forensic Psychologist & PhD Candidate]

Sheikh Akram Buksh [Slacks Creek Mosque, Queensland]

Sheikh Imraan Hussain [Gold Coast Mosque]

Sheikh Khalil Hamed [Victoria]

Mohamad Tabbaa [Terrorism researcher, University of Melbourne]

Mohammed Hoblos [Speaker and Lecturer, NSW]

Rashid Alshakshir [Community Activist & filmmaker, Melbourne]

Rebecca Kay [Community Activist, Sydney]

Sheikh Abdel Aziem Afifi [President, Australian National Imams Council]

Sheikh Abdullah Hawari [Bilal bin Rabah Newport Mosque] [Victoria]

Sheikh Abu Adnan [Markaz Imam Ahmed]

Sheikh Abu Bakr Zaoud [GIYC Liverpool, Sydney, NSW]

Sheikh Eljam Bardi [Shepparton Mosque] [Victoria]

Sheikh Hassan el-Setohy

Sheikh Ibrahim Omerdich [Noble Park Bosnian Mosque] [Victoria]

Sheikh Issa Abdo Musse [Virgin Mary Mosque, Vice President of Board of Imams Victoria]

Sheikh Jamil el-Biza [Ahlul Sunnah Wal Jamah Association]

Sheikh Khalid Issa [Ahlul Sunnah Wal Jamah Association]

Sheikh Khoder Soueid [Victoria]

Sheikh Mohamadu Nawas Saleem [Werribee Mosque, Treasurer of Board of Imams Victoria]

Sheikh Mohamed Mahdi Fitzroy Mosque] [Victoria]

Sheikh Muhamed Djidic [Deer Park Bosnian Mosque] [Victoria]

Sheikh Nazeer ul-Hassan Thanvi [Sydney]

Sheikh Nouredine Laraibi [Taqwa Mosque, Canberra]

Sheikh Omar el-Banna [Al Noor Islamic Association]

Sheikh Rajab Idrizi [Former head of Board of Imams, Victoria]

Sheikh Rami Sharouni

Sheikh Rian Wiramihardja

Sheikh Zuhair Issa [Ahlul Sunnah Wal Jamah Association]

Souha Alemmadine [Community Activist and Events/Projects Co-ordinator]

Tarek Chamkhi [Researcher and Community Activist, Perth]

Ustadh Muhammad Al Bizry [Teacher, activist]

Ustadha Umm Jamal [Teacher]

Will Scates Frances [Writer]

Zulfikar Sharrif [Academic and activist] [Melbourne]

Comments